Pope Leo XIV Now Makes Trump Administration Look Like Hypocrites

VATICAN CITY — In a weekend that blended environmental activism with pointed political jabs, Pope Leo XIV ignited a firestorm among Trump supporters by slamming the administration’s immigration crackdown as “inhuman” and inconsistent with true pro-life values—drawing swift backlash from MAGA voices who branded the pontiff a “hippy” and “woke” interloper.

The Pope’s remarks, delivered at an Italian climate conference on the 10th anniversary of Pope Francis’ landmark encyclical Laudato Si’, come amid escalating U.S. debates over borders and faith, exposing raw tensions between Catholic teachings and Trump’s hardline agenda.

Pope Leo XIV Slams United States’ Leadership

Speaking on October 1, 2025, at the “Raising Hope for Climate Justice” gathering in Albano Laziale, Pope Leo XIV didn’t mince words on global leaders’ climate inaction, indirectly targeting skeptics like President Donald Trump, who just days earlier at the United Nations General Assembly dismissed climate change as “the greatest con job ever perpetrated on the world.”

“World leaders should act with courage” on the crisis, the Pope urged, blessing a chunk of melting Greenland glacier during the event—a symbolic nod to the environmental legacy of his predecessor, who died in April.

But it was the Pope’s immigration critique that really set off alarms in conservative circles. Earlier in the week, Leo XIV had decried the U.S. treatment of migrants as a betrayal of Christian mercy.

On Sunday, he doubled down, tying it directly to pro-life hypocrisy: “And someone who says I’m against abortion but I’m in agreement with the inhuman treatment of immigrants in the United States, I don’t know if that’s pro-life.”

He went further, lumping in support for the death penalty: “Someone who says I’m against abortion but is in favor of the death penalty is not really pro-life.”

Those lines landed like a thunderclap for Trump’s evangelical and Catholic base, who have long championed his anti-abortion stance as a moral triumph.

The Pope’s words spotlight a glaring contradiction: The administration’s mass deportation raids—now ramping up with ICE arrests in sanctuary cities and family separations at the border—clash head-on with Catholic social doctrine that views migrants as vulnerable lives deserving protection.

It’s a hypocrisy that’s hard to ignore, especially when Trump touts himself as the pro-life champion while greenlighting policies that tear families apart and endanger migrant children in detention centers.

The Call for the Protection of Earth

Leo XIV’s call for “courage” on climate adds another layer, underscoring how Trump’s dismissal of environmental threats as a “hoax” ignores the pontifical plea to safeguard creation as a pro-life imperative—protecting future generations from pollution and scarcity.

The MAGA reaction was swift and scorching. Conservative commentator Matt Walsh, a Catholic convert known for his culture-war crusades, dismissed the Pope’s glacier blessing as a “weird hippy ‘climate justice’ ritual.”

Alt-right firebrand Jack Posobiec amplified a video of the ceremony, questioning, “how is this helping Christians who fear communists are shooting us and our children and burning down churches around the world.”

On social media, the backlash snowballed: A Trump supporter from South Carolina lamented, “Should have known the Catholic Church would put in another woke Pope.”

Another woman vented, “When you pray for a ‘less woke pope’ and you get this,” capping it with a frustrated “for f–-k’s sake”.

Whether you like the Pope or not, nothing about his comments came off as ‘woke’ ideologies.

And whether it stings or not, he has a point when it comes to the hypocrisy — or at least contradictions of what the administration stands for regarding pro-life.

“Good Girl” Karoline Leavitt Defends Trump

Karoline Leavitt response to Pope Leo XIV

White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt, a practicing Catholic who’s defended Trump’s faith-based initiatives, pushed back gently but firmly.

“This administration is trying to enforce our nation’s laws in the most humane way possible, and we are upholding the law. We are doing that on behalf of the people of our country who live here,” she said in a statement.

It’s a line that echoes the administration’s broader defense of its border policies, but it sidesteps the Pope’s deeper challenge.

Can a truly pro-life ethic square with turning away the vulnerable at the border?

The Pope’s words also carried a subtle olive branch to Democrats. On Friday, Leo XIV endorsed a lifetime achievement award for Illinois Sen. Dick Durbin from a Catholic institution, despite Durbin’s support for abortion rights.

Perhaps he should have done a little more homework…

“I wasn’t very familiar with the case,” the Pope admitted, praising Durbin’s “overall work” over four decades in Congress.

Durbin, visibly moved, called it “quite a moment” and “overwhelming.”

As the dust settles, Leo XIV’s intervention feels like a timely gut-check for American Catholics divided between faith and politics.

Trump’s team has leaned on pro-life wins like overturning Roe v. Wade, but the Pope’s rebuke forces a reckoning: If life is sacred from conception, why not extend that mercy to migrants fleeing violence or families caught in deportation nets?

In a midterm season already awash in culture clashes, this incredibly important pivot could sway swing-state voters—and remind MAGA that even the Vatican isn’t buying the selective sanctity line.

Contact | About | Home