- Trump administration’s aggressive deportation surge has led to nearly 200,000 removals in seven months, straining due process and causing errors.
- Alejandro Juarez—longtime Trump club worker—was mistakenly deported without a hearing, highlighting systemic procedural failures and human cost.
- Court rulings, lawsuits, and public backlash warn that fast‑track policies risk wrongful removals, family separations, and constitutional violations.
Alejandro Juarez had spent more than a decade hustling through the manicured greens of the Trump National Golf Club Westchester, serving up hors d’oeuvres to the elite and running food for high-rollers who probably never noticed the man behind the tray.
He was the kind of reliable worker who blended into the background—until the background decided to boot him out of the country he called home for over two decades.
On a sweltering September day, Juarez, 39, showed up for what he thought was a routine check-in with Immigration and Customs Enforcement in Manhattan.
The FrankNez Media Daily Briefing newsletter provides all the news you need to start your day. Sign up here.
Instead, he was slapped in handcuffs, shuttled onto the wrong plane, and dumped across the Rio Grande into Mexico—five days before his scheduled immigration hearing.
Standing on that bridge, staring at the border he’d crossed illegally at 16, Juarez begged the agents to reconsider. “It was very hard, deported without giving me an opportunity to defend my case,” he later told reporters through tears during a phone interview from his father’s farm.
This isn’t just one man’s heartbreak; it’s a stark example of the Trump administration’s high-stakes deportation push gone awry.
Since President Donald Trump returned to the White House in January, ICE has ramped up removals to levels not seen in a decade, deporting nearly 200,000 people in the first seven months alone.
The administration touts these numbers as a fulfillment of campaign promises, but critics—and now even federal judges—are sounding alarms over the human cost of what they call a “breakneck pace” that skips due process and invites errors.
Details of Juarez’s Case
Juarez’s story, first detailed in a New York Times investigation, reads like a Kafkaesque thriller. He crossed into the U.S. in 2002, learned English on the fly, and built a life in Westchester County with his wife—who’s pursuing a green card—and their four children, two of whom are U.S. citizens.
His job at the Trump club’s upscale dining room kept the lights on; he was there from 2007 until 2019, when a government shutdown over border wall funding exposed the irony of his employment.
That year, amid Trump’s first-term crackdown on undocumented workers, Juarez and about a dozen colleagues were fired en masse. Eric Trump had even greeted him warmly at a holiday party just weeks earlier, clapping him on the back and saying, “Thanks, Alejandro. Thanks for everything, okay?”
But loyalty, it seems, has a short shelf life in the Trump Organization. The firings made national headlines, with workers like Margarita Cruz, another laid-off employee, decrying the hypocrisy: “They knew we were undocumented… now they act surprised.”
Life post-firing wasn’t easy, but Juarez kept his head down. A 2022 DUI arrest—while driving with his wife and two kids—landed him three years’ probation and put him on ICE’s radar.
He checked in periodically, complying with every summons. That compliance led to his September 15 detention.
What followed was a cascade of missteps: ICE intended to transfer him to an Arizona detention center for his hearing, but agents loaded him onto a deportation flight to Texas instead. There, unshackled on the International Bridge in Laredo, he was instructed to walk into Mexico.
Back in New York, confusion reigned. Juarez’s attorney, Anibal Romero, arrived at the September 25 hearing alone. “This is unprecedented in my 20 years of practice—an individual being removed without any hearing, leaving even the court and DHS confused,” Romero told the Times.
An ICE lawyer in the courtroom admitted they had no idea where Juarez was. Initially, DHS stonewalled reporters, claiming he was still detained over the DUI. Only later did they fess up: “removed to Mexico early because he was put on the incorrect transport.”
Their fix? Bring him back into custody—for a do-over deportation, this time with the paperwork in order. Juarez, meanwhile, is holed up on his family’s farmland, helping tend crops while his kids attend school without him. “I was never given a chance to contest my deportation,” he said, his voice cracking over the line.
Violations of Due Process Raise Constitutional Concerns
Federal immigration law entitles most facing removal to a judge’s review—a step skipped here, potentially violating statutes and the Fifth Amendment’s due process clause.
It’s unclear how many others have slipped through similar cracks; ICE doesn’t systematically track wrongful expulsions.
This isn’t an isolated screw-up. Juarez’s plight echoes a string of high-profile blunders under Trump’s renewed enforcement machine. Take Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia, a Maryland father with protected status who was shipped to El Salvador’s notorious CECOT megaprison in March—despite a court order barring his removal.
The administration called it an “administrative error” but accused him of MS-13 ties he denied; the Supreme Court eventually forced officials to “facilitate” his return, though not before months of legal wrangling.
A federal judge lambasted the government for “willful and bad faith” obstruction in the case, per PBS reporting.
Ex-DOJ lawyer Erez Reuveni’s superiors pushed him to argue in court that Garcia was an MS-13 gang member and terrorist, which Reuveni knew was false.
“I responded up the chain of command, no way. That is not correct,” he said. “That is not factually correct. It is not legally correct. That is a lie. And I cannot sign my name to that brief.”
For refusing, he was fired, ending his long DOJ career, and he filed a whistleblower complaint in June.
Then there’s Daniel Lozano-Camargo, a Venezuelan asylum seeker deported to El Salvador in March against a settlement mandating his claim be heard first.
Or the anonymous O.C.G., bounced to Mexico based on a glitchy software note in ICE’s ENFORCE system that falsely claimed he was unafraid to leave—another admission of tech-fueled folly.
Broader patterns are emerging too: A 2022 DHS civil rights probe uncovered a Guatemalan man deported sans final order, prompting calls for better rectification processes.
And while DHS insists it never deports U.S. citizens, investigative reporting has documented over 170 wrongful detentions of Americans in recent years, including kids and veterans, with some spiraling into near-misses for removal.
Historic Numbers, But at What Price?
The backdrop is Trump’s deportation juggernaut, which has seen over 400,000 removals since Inauguration Day, per DHS tallies—on track for 600,000 by year’s end.
But the numbers mask the mess: Internal stats show less than 10% of those in ICE custody since late 2024 have criminal records, let alone violent ones, contradicting vows to target the “worst of the worst.”
Frustrated with the tempo, the White House is plotting a shake-up at ICE, eyeing demotions for field bosses and infusions of Border Patrol agents known for their border-hardened aggression.
Stephen Miller, the policy’s architect, has pushed for 3,000 daily arrests; September clocked in at under 1,200.
Advocates aren’t waiting for fixes. The ACLU and groups like Make the Road New York have sued to halt “fast-track” policies that ambush immigrants at courthouses, dismissing cases on the spot to enable swift removals without hearings.
A federal judge blocked one such expansion in August, citing risks of “wrongful deportation” for thousands.
“This administration’s reckless attempt to deprive people of their legal rights… puts everyone at risk,” warned Sienna Fontaine of Make the Road.
Public sentiment is souring too. A YouGov/Economist poll this week pegged Trump’s approval at a dismal low, with 57% disapproving—driven in part by backlash to immigration tactics that ensnare families and long-timers like Juarez.
Pew found most Americans back some deportations but draw the line at splitting up families or targeting nonviolent folks.
For now, Juarez waits in limbo, his American dream deferred by a clerical cock-up. ICE says it’s “facilitating” his return—for round two. But as the administration doubles down, one thing’s clear: In the rush to “secure the border,” the real casualties are lives caught in the crossfire.
How many more Alejandro Juarezes will it take before the system hits pause?
Also Read: A DOJ Whistleblower Now Makes Revelation That Undermines the Judicial System’s Integrity
